6 sculpts matched · strictly 18+
Goldilocks› SquarePeg› Alternatives
Alternatives

Like SquarePeg, from another maker.

Maybe your favourite SquarePeg sculpt is sold through, or you just want to see what else fits the same before you commit. For each of their best-documented pieces, our fit engine finds the closest sizes across the other makers we track — measured the same way, with every difference from the SquarePeg original spelled out on the card.

Instead of the Sounds

Ranked against SquarePeg's 28 Short — — around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Merfolk

Merfolk

Pleasure Forge
the Large
near-identical size
girth 8.1″
usable 7.0″
Machoman

Machoman

Mr Hankey's Toys
the Original
near-identical size
girth 7.2″
usable 7.0″
$134.95
no reviews yet — be first
Ray Diesel

Ray Diesel

Mr Hankey's Toys
the XS
near-identical size
girth 5.5″
usable 7.0″
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Troll

Troll

Pleasure Forge
the Large
near-identical size
girth 8.1″
usable 7.0″

Instead of the Blunt Plug

Ranked against SquarePeg's S6 — 7.0″ around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Ceela

Ceela

Strange Bedfellas
the Medium
≈+0.25" length ~
girth 7.0″
usable 4.8″
Chonk

Chonk

Fantasy Grove
the Medium
≈+0.5" length ~
girth 7.0″
usable 5.0″
$75
no reviews yet — be first
Changeling

Changeling

Fantasy Grove
the Medium
≈+0.5" length ~ softer
girth 7.0″
usable 5.0″
$75
no reviews yet — be first

Instead of the Splitter 2.0

Ranked against SquarePeg's Small — 9.6″ around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Taurion the Minotaur

Taurion the Minotaur

Bad Dragon
the Small
−0.25" girth ≈+1.5" length ~
girth 9.4″
usable 5.8″
$90
no reviews yet — be first
Joh

Joh

Strange Bedfellas
the Large
≈+0.75" length ~ firmer knotted
girth 9.5″
usable 5.0″
The Rabbit

The Rabbit

Mr Hankey's Toys
the Small
≈+1.75" length ~ firmer
girth 9.5″
usable 6.0″
$129.95
no reviews yet — be first
Changeling

Changeling

Fantasy Grove
the Large
+0.25" girth ≈+2" length ~
girth 9.8″
usable 6.3″
$75
no reviews yet — be first

Instead of the Egg Plug

Ranked against SquarePeg's L XL — 7.3″ around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Uthur's Tongue

Uthur's Tongue

Strange Bedfellas
the Large
≈+0.25" length ~
girth 7.2″
usable 5.2″
$80
no reviews yet — be first
Lon

Lon

Strange Bedfellas
the Small
≈+0.25" length ~
girth 7.2″
usable 5.2″
Phaethon

Phaethon

Creature Feature Toys
the Medium
≈+0.25" length ~
girth 7.2″
usable 5.2″
Ogre

Ogre

Pleasure Forge
the Medium
≈+0.5" length ~ softer
girth 7.2″
usable 5.3″

Instead of the G squeeze

Ranked against SquarePeg's Large — 6.7″ around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Dryad

Dryad

Wandering Bard Toys
the Small
≈+0.25" length ~
girth 6.8″
usable 4.7″
Rakshasa

Rakshasa

Wandering Bard Toys
the Small
≈+1" length ~ firmer
girth 6.7″
usable 5.4″
Dwarven Barbarian

Dwarven Barbarian

Wandering Bard Toys
the Small
≈+1" length ~ softer
girth 6.7″
usable 5.4″
Kraken Rogue

Kraken Rogue

Pleasure Forge
the Medium
≈+0.75" length ~
girth 6.8″
usable 5.2″
$70
no reviews yet — be first

Instead of the Happy Hour Plug

Ranked against SquarePeg's Small — 8.2″ around. Differences are the other toy vs theirs. See the original →
Halichoer

Halichoer

Pleasure Forge
the Large
≈+0.25" length ~ softer
girth 8.2″
usable 6.4″
$90
no reviews yet — be first
Hydrochroma

Hydrochroma

Pleasure Forge
the Large
≈+0.5" length ~ softer
girth 8.2″
usable 6.5″
Amanita

Amanita

Fantasy Grove
the Large
softer
girth 8.3″
usable 6.0″
$75
no reviews yet — be first
Ziq

Ziq

Strange Bedfellas
the Medium
≈−0.25" length ~ softer
girth 8.3″
usable 5.7″

Prefer to drive it yourself? The fit engine takes any reference — even a toy you already own — and lets you nudge girth, length, firmness and knot.

Find my fit → All SquarePeg sculpts