Goldilocks› Browse› XL Thicky Nicky vs XXXL Thicky Nicky

XL vs XXXL Thicky Nicky

Two rungs of the same ladder: Mr Hankey's Toys’s Thicky Nicky in XL and XXXL — drawn on top of each other to scale, so the step between them is something you can see rather than subtract.

XL Thicky Nicky by Mr Hankey's Toys

XL Thicky Nicky Mr Hankey's Toys

girth10.8″ usable 8.0″ feelsoft–extra-firm

XXXL Thicky Nicky by Mr Hankey's Toys

XXXL Thicky Nicky Mr Hankey's Toys

girth12.5″ usable 9.3″ feelsoft–extra-firm

One on top of the other

Both outlines on one axis, at the same scale. Sizes come from the makers’ published girths; where a usable cut-out exists, the profile itself is traced from it. Where they overlap they’re the same; the gap is the difference.

Show a soda can

XL Thicky Nicky8.0″ usable · widest shaft point 10.8″
XXXL Thicky Nicky9.3″ usable · widest shaft point 12.5″

Side by side at the same scale

Drawn to scale: sizes from published girths, and the profile traced from the cut-out where we have one. Point positions along the shaft are approximate.

Show a soda can

How the numbers compare

Differences of about ¼ inch or more are highlighted. Blanks mean the maker doesn’t publish that point.

	XL Thicky Nicky	XXXL Thicky Nicky
Usable length	8.0″	9.3″
Total length	11.5″	13.0″
Widest girth	10.8″	12.5″
Narrowest girth	8.9″	10.2″
Tip girth	8.9″	10.2″
Mid girth	10.8″	12.5″
Base girth	10.6″	12.1″
Firmness options	soft–extra-firm	soft–extra-firm
Knot	no	no

Which one should you get?

Every line generated from the spec deltas above.

Stepping up from the XL to the XXXL adds 1.7″ of girth: 10.8″ around becomes 12.5″.
That’s over an inch in one step. Owners who’ve worked up sizes generally suggest half an inch to an inch of girth at a time, so this is a jump rather than a nudge — the one to be careful with if the XL already sits near your limit.
The XXXL is the longer of the two: 8.0″ of usable length becomes 9.3″.
Both sizes come in the same firmness options (soft–extra-firm), so feel isn’t a variable here — only size is.
Between the two? There’s no rung between them in the sizes we track for this sculpt — so it’s the XL, or a different sculpt that lands in the gap.

See the XL Thicky Nicky → See the XXXL Thicky Nicky →

The other sizes of this sculpt

Same sculpt, the other steps in its size ladder — each one measured the same way.

Build your own comparison — any two to four toys →