226 sizes · strictly 18+
Goldilocks› Browse› Extra-firm toys

Extra-firm toys

Barely any give at all. Everything here can be poured in the firmest silicone on offer, for people who want the shape to push back and stay exactly as sculpted.

Worth knowing before you buy: firm reads bigger than soft at identical measurements, because none of the girth squashes away. If a number feels borderline, size down when you go firm.

100+ sculpts · 226 sizes Filter the whole shelf yourself →
Duke by Mr Hankey's Toys

Duke

Mr Hankey's Toys
original · poured to order
girth 7.0″
usable 6.3″
feel 3 feels
$129.95
no reviews yet — be first
Isaac X by Mr Hankey's Toys

Isaac X

Mr Hankey's Toys
original · poured to order
girth 7.8″
usable 7.5″
feel 3 feels
$146.95
no reviews yet — be first
Jack Hunter by Mr Hankey's Toys

Jack Hunter

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.0″
usable 7.0″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
The Mikey by Mr Hankey's Toys

The Mikey

Mr Hankey's Toys
original · poured to order
girth 8.7″
usable 7.5″
feel 3 feels
$141.95
no reviews yet — be first
Aaron Klein by Mr Hankey's Toys

Aaron Klein

Mr Hankey's Toys
original · poured to order
girth 7.2″
usable 6.0″
feel 3 feels
$129.95
no reviews yet — be first
Assbergé Egg Plug by Mr Hankey's Toys

Assbergé Egg Plug

Mr Hankey's Toys
xl · poured to order
girth 11.0″
usable 8.1″
feel 3 feels
$139.95
no reviews yet — be first
Handyman Butt Plug by Mr Hankey's Toys

Handyman Butt Plug

Mr Hankey's Toys
med/lg · poured to order
girth 8.5″
usable 6.5″
feel 3 feels
$124.95
no reviews yet — be first
Captain's Hook by Mr Hankey's Toys

Captain's Hook

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 5.7″
usable 6.6″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Dana's Grip by Mr Hankey's Toys

Dana's Grip

Mr Hankey's Toys
small/med · poured to order
girth 7.8″
usable 7.8″
feel 3 feels
$134.95
no reviews yet — be first
Marco Napoli by Mr Hankey's Toys

Marco Napoli

Mr Hankey's Toys
original · poured to order
girth 6.1″
usable 6.0″
feel 3 feels
$124.95
no reviews yet — be first
Omega by Mr Hankey's Toys

Omega

Mr Hankey's Toys
medium · poured to order
girth 8.7″
usable 8.0″
feel 3 feels
$163.95
no reviews yet — be first
Dildos & Dragons by Mr Hankey's Toys

Dildos & Dragons

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 5.9″
usable 6.5″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Horse Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Horse Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
large · poured to order
girth 10.7″
usable 10.0″
feel 3 feels
$159.95
no reviews yet — be first
Double Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Double Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.3″
usable 5.0″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Dog Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Dog Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.5″
usable 6.5″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Thicky Nicky by Mr Hankey's Toys

Thicky Nicky

Mr Hankey's Toys
large · poured to order
girth 9.3″
usable 6.8″
feel 3 feels
$153.95
no reviews yet — be first
Hungerff by Mr Hankey's Toys

Hungerff

Mr Hankey's Toys
small · poured to order
girth 7.6″
usable 6.1″
feel 3 feels
$125.95
no reviews yet — be first
Corn Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Corn Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
small · poured to order
girth 6.6″
usable 5.7″
feel 3 feels
$89.96
no reviews yet — be first
Hentai Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Hentai Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
small · poured to order
girth 8.3″
usable 6.5″
feel 3 feels
$125.95
no reviews yet — be first
The Perfect Penis by Mr Hankey's Toys

The Perfect Penis

Mr Hankey's Toys
small · poured to order
girth 5.0″
usable 6.5″
feel 3 feels
$125.95
no reviews yet — be first
Monster Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Monster Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.0″
usable 5.2″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Bbc Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Bbc Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.0″
usable 5.5″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Horse Dildo Ii by Mr Hankey's Toys

Horse Dildo Ii

Mr Hankey's Toys
xs · poured to order
girth 6.5″
usable 7.2″
feel 3 feels
$65.95
no reviews yet — be first
Unicorn Dildo by Mr Hankey's Toys

Unicorn Dildo

Mr Hankey's Toys
small · poured to order
girth 4.8″
usable 7.0″
feel 3 feels
$134.95
no reviews yet — be first

Related shelves

Big and firm toys Sculpts 8″+ around and poured firm or extra-firm — real presence, none of the give. Widest girth listed per size, with live stock from the makers we track. Firm knotted toys Knotted toys poured firm, so the knot holds its shape and you feel every bit of the catch. Per-size girth and stock across the indie makers we track. Firm butt plugs Plug-shaped sculpts poured firm or extra-firm — they hold their shape and give you that unmistakable sense of fullness. Girth and neck per size. The whole shelf Every size we track, with the full filter rail — shape, feel, girth, length, colourway and maker.